When someone marks a torrent bad, it'd be nice if they would have to provide a reason that only the uploader would see. (Like constructive feedback).

Also, it'd be nice if in the Reputation list, when someone gives you a rep-point (or takes one away) that the Reputation List would provide a link to that thread, post or comment.

It'd be nice if there could be a list of posts in our profile, a list of posts that we have created. It could provide a link, name of thread and if any reputation was given or not. I'm curious as to what people are giving me rep-points for and what I said that made them feel like giving me some.

Still in Draft m8, you have to wait for the Techs to change it to 'under review'.

You can't have a feedback system that does not allow for negative feedback, what would be the point when your rep can only go up? People need to realise that there actions have consequences, here on KAT that means your rep can go up n down, in the scheme of things maybe not that important but its the system we have until someone suggests something better :)

Gonna boost your ego a bit. You are correct, Boobs. Unless we get rid of a rep system altogether.

1st thing mentioned about the constructive feedback is golden. i really hope this gets implemented! is there already an ideabox idea for it?

Finally, the constructive feedback idea is under review.
http://kat.ph/ideabox/show/constructive-feedback/